Carling Cup verdict: Manchester City 2 Manchester United 1

Carlos Tevez stole the headlines with two goals as City came from behind to beat a full-strength United in the first leg of the Carling Cup semi-final. Nothing can be taken for granted in the second leg as United showed their danger with a late onslaught, but at least City fans could go home happy with a win on the night.

Carling Cup player ratings: Manchester City v Manchester United

Given – The match was in danger of descending into a duel between Shay and Rooney. Thankfully Shay was still winning when the referee blew for time. 8

Richards – An improvement on his display in the last derby, but still needs to get tighter on wingers as wily as Giggs. 7